Despite their apparent accord on Syria, Mr. Obama and Mr. Hollande were
reminded again of the limits of their ability to act, when Russia doubled down
on its opposition to a United Nations resolution designed to free up
desperately needed humanitarian aid for war-ravaged civilians. Analysts say pressure on Russia, whether it comes from the U.S., France or
anywhere else, will have limited impact. That didn't stop Mr. Obama and Mr. Hollande — on a three-day U.S. visit
that included an extravagant state dinner at the White House on Tuesday evening
— from using the bully pulpit of a joint press conference to condemn Moscow's
obstructionism and call for an end to the fighting in Syria. "There is great unanimity among most of the Security Council on this
resolution [to provide greater aid]. Russia is a holdout," Mr. Obama told
a gathering of French and U.S. journalists. "And Secretary [of State John
F.] Kerry and others have delivered a very direct message to the Russians that
they cannot say they are concerned about the well-being of the Syrian people
when there are starving civilians. ... [I]t is not just the Syrians that are
responsible; the Russians, as well, if they are blocking this kind of
resolution." Mr. Hollande echoed those remarks, questioning how Russia could stand in
the way of providing food, water, medicine and other supplies to the Syrian
people. "How can you object to humanitarian corridors? Why would you prevent
the vote of a resolution if, in good faith, it is all about saving human
lives?" he said. As they directed criticism at Russia, athletes from the U.S., France and
other nations around the world were competing in Sochi. The Olympics
traditionally have led to something of a truce among nations, though there's
little sign that the frayed relations between Russia and its foes have been
soothed at all by the spirit of international athletic competition. Mr. Obama, Mr. Hollande and most other Western political leaders skipped
the Sochi Games. The official U.S. delegation, including a number of prominent
gay Americans, was widely seen as slap at Russian legislation targeting
homosexuals. Analysts on both sides saw a Russian riposte in Mr. Putin's choice
of a former Olympic figure skater who publicly made a racist joke about Mr.
Obama and first lady Michelle Obama to help light the torch in Sochi. As the civil war worsens and U.N.-sponsored peace talks make little
progress, Russia is standing firm in its longtime support of Syrian President
Bashar Assad — who has used chemical weapons against his own people on multiple
occasions — and in opposition to any resolutions condemning his regime. "Our Western partners in the Security Council ... proposed that we
cooperate in working out a resolution. The ideas they shared with us were
absolutely one-sided and detached from reality," Russian Foreign Minister
Sergey Lavrov told the Interfax news agency. He said the humanitarian resolution amounts to little more than
"one-sided accusations aimed at the regime."
Foreign policy observers say that while an international coalition
negotiated a last-minute deal last summer with the Assad regime to destroy its
chemical weapons stockpiles, there simply aren't many cards left to play if
Russia continues to stand in the way of a full resolution of the crisis. "I think Russia is going to do what Russia is going to do. Russia has
its own interests. It is looking to accomplish the goals Russia feels are
within its own geopolitical sphere. ... It's hard to say France would
necessarily have any more leverage" than the U.S., said Robert Kron, a
senior analyst at the Center for European Policy Analysis who specializes in
European defense and trans-Atlantic security. Mr. Kron noted that France under Mr. Hollande often has appeared more
willing than the U.S. to use military force against the Assad regime. Indeed,
in the weeks leading up to last year's chemical weapons agreement that helped
avert military strikes, it was Mr. Hollande's government that most vocally
pushed for action in Syria. Still, Mr. Hollande and Mr. Obama favor a diplomatic end to the conflict
rather than military intervention. But such an outcome appears no closer than it did a few months ago. "We are not making much progress," U.N.-Arab League Joint Special
Representative Lakhdar Brahimi said Tuesday from Geneva, where peace talks
between the Assad government and rebel forces resumed Monday. "We all owe
it to the Syrian people to move a little bit faster than we are doing." The United Nations also reported that at least 500,000 Syrians are unable
to access food, clean water and other aid supplies because of security
concerns. Snipers believed to be part of Mr. Assad's forces have fired on
humanitarian convoys in parts of the country. In addition to Syria, Mr. Obama and Mr. Hollande also attempted to present
a unified front on Iran, where the U.S., France and other international
partners have secured an agreement under which Iran will roll back parts of its
nuclear program in exchange for a gradual easing of international sanctions. There was a hint of pre-meeting tension when Mr. Kerry and other U.S.
officials criticized as "not helpful" a major French trade delegation
that descended on Tehran this month in anticipation of deals if and when the
sanctions are removed. Israel and other critics of the outreach to Iran have
warned that business considerations could trump security concerns in dealing
with Iran's nuclear programs. Mr. Obama gave a stark warning to Western businesses that prematurely try
to cut deals with Iran. "I can tell you that they do so at their own peril right now because
we will come down on them like a ton of bricks with respect to the sanctions
that we control," he said. Mr. Hollande countered that he did not control the actions of private
French trade delegations. "The president of the republic is not the president of the employers
union in France, and he certainly doesn't wish to be," he said.
"Companies make their decisions when it comes to traveling, but I
certainly let them know that sanctions were in force and would remain in
force." | |
PUBLICATIONS | |
1358 reads | 13.02.2014 |